satanic verses page 307mary calderon quintanilla
on the Internet. ", "Freedom of Information and Expression in India", "Firebombs Damage 2 Berkeley Book Shops: Another Hits N.Y. The view of many Muslims was that "Rushdie has portrayed the prophet of Islam as a brothel keeper". Search the history of over 778 billion Typical. [12]:294,300, According to Ibn Taymiyyah: "The early Islamic Scholars (Salaf) collectively considered the Verses of Cranes in accordance with Quran. In the whole mosque there was no believer or kfir who did not prostrate. [citation needed] The twelve members of the European Economic Community removed their ambassadors from Tehran for three weeks. "[2], After the Satanic Verses controversy developed, some scholars familiar with the book and the whole of Rushdie's work, like M. D. Fletcher, saw the reaction as ironic. 12 February 1989: Six people are killed and 100 injured when 10,000 attack the American Cultural Center in. B. Dalton bookstore chain received 30 threats in less than three hours. [115] Nobel prize winners Wole Soyinka of Nigeria and Naguib Mahfouz of Egypt, both attacked Khomeini, and both received death threats as a result, with Mahfouz later getting stabbed in the neck by a Muslim fundamentalist. It broke diplomatic relations with UK on 7 March 1989 giving the explanation that "in the past two centuries Britain has been in the frontline of plots and treachery against Islam and Muslims". [11], Rushdie's influences have long been a point of interest to scholars examining his work. [24], In March 2016, the bounty for the Rushdie fatwa was raised by $600,000 (430,000). He alleges that the Muslims had to establish the story of Muhammad's life on the same literary patterns as were used in the vitae of the other prophets". During an argument the terrorists accidentally detonate a bomb, destroying the aircraft over the English Channel. [12]:295, Several related traditions exist, some adapted to Qur'nic material, some not. "Iran: West to Blame Islam for Forthcoming Terrorism", Bernard Lewis commenting on Rushdie fatwa in, Radio Tehran, 16 March 1989, quoted in Pipes, 1990, p. 135. President Khomeini accused them of attempting to use religious law as "a flag under which they can crush revolutionary Islam".[53]. Based on the book's title, and out of a general ignorance about what it references, a misunderstanding in the part of people in Muslim majority countries, where the book was not available, that led to the mistaken belief that the book was a "Satanist" critique of Islam and the Prophet Muhammad. 20 October 1988: Union of Muslim Organisations of the UK writes the British government pressing for a ban of. 24 December 1990: Rushdie signs a declaration affirming his Islamic faith and calls for Viking-Penguin, the publisher of, 2 July 1993: Thirty-seven Turkish intellectuals and locals participating in the, 11 August 1993: Rushdie makes a rare public appearance at. Tesei argues that those verses display stylistic incoherence as well as a theological tension with the rest of Q. I honestly never expected anything like this". Living as we do in a world of many faiths, this experience has served to remind us that we must all be conscious of the sensibilities of others. You have recited to the people something which I have not brought you from God, and you have spoken what He did not say to you. [25] A complaint by one of the characters about communal violence in India: "Fact is, religious faith, which encodes the highest aspirations of human race, is now, in our country, the servant of lowest instincts, and God is the creature of evil". About Our Coalition. . League for the Spread of Unpopular Views. [43], Other leaders, while supporting the fatwa, claimed that British Muslims were not allowed to carry out the fatwa themselves.[why?] There are the archangels and the goddesses we meet in Gibreel's dreams, but the narrator is perhaps the most potent higher power of all. [68][69][70][71] The assailant stabbed him ten times, straining to continue the attack even as several people held him back. The government of Iran denied having foreknowledge of the stabbing, although Iranian state-controlled media celebrated it. It accused the British of sponsoring Rushdie's book to use it as a political and cultural tactic on earlier military plots that no longer worked. [citation needed], The title The Satanic Verses immediately sparked vehement protest against Rushdie's book. It is sheer blasphemy to say that satanic forces can influence the messengers of Allah.[24][25]. But they also hold damaging implications in regard to the revelation as a whole, for Muhammad's revelation appears to have been based on his desire to soften the threat to the deities of the people. Snow Princess. However, when Gibreel finds Saladin in a burning building, he rescues him. The book's Turkish translator Aziz Nesin was the intended target of a mob of arsonists who set fire to the Madimak Hotel after Friday prayers on 2 July 1993 in Sivas, Turkey, killing 37 people, mostly Alevi scholars, poets and musicians. Book tag (s): Ameer-e-Ahle Sunnat Digital screenshot from the PDF Book and books aren't burned or banned, The Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran has no intention, nor is it going to take any action whatsoever, to threaten the life of the author of The Satanic Verses or anybody associated with his work, nor will it encourage or assist anybody to do so".[2]. She entices all her village community to embark on a foot pilgrimage to Mecca, claiming that they will be able to walk across the Arabian Sea. Others lose faith. [30] By 14 August, Rushdie was off the ventilator and able to talk. The novel contains some fictionalized allusions to Islamic history, which provoked both controversy and outrage. [12], The Satanic Verses was published by Viking Penguin on 26 September 1988 in the UK, and on 22 February 1989 in the US. Capture a web page as it appears now for use as a trusted citation in the future. [77] Media expressions of this included a banner headline in the popular British newspaper the Daily Mirror referring to Khomeini as "that Mad Mullah". Fletcher wrote "It is perhaps a relevant irony that some of the major expressions of hostility toward Rushdie came from those about whom and (in some sense) for whom he wrote. [52], Iran's response to calls for a trial was to denounce its Islamic proponents as "deceitful". Rubin makes similar comments about an isnad involving another companion, Makhrama bin Nawfal. Upon learning that his father is dying, Saladin returns to Bombay and reconciles with him. [20], The BBC broadcast in 2021 a two-hour documentary by Mobeen Azhar and Chloe Hadjimatheou, interviewing many of the principal denouncers and defenders of the book 1988-1989, concluding that campaigns against the book were amplified by minority (racial and religious) politics in England and other countries. "When Europeans saw that their economic interests in Muslim countries could be damaged, they began to correct their position on the issue of the insulting book. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. And when one incident is reported from many different chains, then it means there is something real in this incident. Iran has rejected requests to withdraw the fatwa on the basis that only the person who issued it may withdraw it. Thus, whether the phrase had intended to attribute a divine nature to the three "idols" is a matter of dispute. On 18 February, Iran's President Ali Khamenei (who would later that year succeed Khomeini as Supreme Leader) suggested that if Rushdie "apologises and disowns the book, people may forgive him". The Satanic Verses also exhibits Rushdie's common practice of using allusions to invoke connotative links. Southern New Hampshire University. A third story line is introduced through another dream of Gibreels. [72][73] A doctor, who was present for the lecture, immediately tended to Rushdie. 22 February 2016: A group of forty state-run media organisations in Iran raised $600,000 to add to the Fatwa on Rushdie. "Salman Rushdie: The Accidental Intellectual in the Mediascape. Some traditions even describe his eventual comeuppance, saying he is later killed at the battle of Badr. Then everybody dispersed from the mosque. [61] John Crowley has noted that the section of the book depicting the Khomeini-like character was selected to be read publicly by Rushdie in the promotional events leading up to and following the book's release. In another moment of crisis, Farishta realises what Chamcha has done, but forgives him and even saves his life. [39], In addition to criticism of the death sentence on the basis of human rights, the sentence was also criticised on Islamic grounds. This page is having a slideshow that uses Javascript. . The story was accepted by religious authorities for the first two centuries of the Islamic era, but was later rejected by religious scholars (Ulama) from the 13th century onward as incompatible with Muhammad's "perfection" ('isma), implying that Muhammad is infallible and therefore cannot be fooled by Satan. [7] Chamcha is an emigrant who has broken with his Indian identity and works as a voiceover artist in England. Shahab Ahmed states that "Reports of the Satanic verses incident were recorded by virtually every compiler of a major biography of Muhammad in the first two centuries of Islam: 'Urwah b. al-Zubayr (2394), Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri (51124), Musa b. Wiggins's novel John Dollar was inscribed "To my beloved Salman"; The Satanic Verses, simply "For Marianne." The couple's lives turned to nightmare soon after Verses was published in Britain. And about the third deity, al-Mant?". "[22] Different responses have developed concerning the account. [12] In March 1989, it was also banned in Malaysia. Fletcher. Shining), Al-Lat 8, 91, 100, 105, 107, 110, 111, 114, 116, 119-121, Although the British Conservative government under Margaret Thatcher gave Rushdie round-the-clock police protection, many politicians on both sides were hostile to the author. 'By the star when it sets! Im Totally Fine 2022 1080p WEB-DL DD5 1 H 264-EVO. Later, the logic of the era of hadith collections and subsequent orthodoxy required an infallible prophet. "All this Western art-house crap." His top ten of everything came from "back home", and was aggressively lowbrow. [87], The author of the book himself was not immediately killed or injured as many militants wished, but visibly frustrated by a life locked in 24-hour armed guard alternately defiant against his would-be killers and attempting overtures of reconciliation against the death threat. Winner of the Whitbread Prize for Best Novel, A staggering achievement, brilliantly enjoyable.Nadine Gordimer, [A] torrent of endlessly inventive prose, by turns comic and enraged, embracing life in all its contradictions. Arguments for rejection are found in Muhammad Abduh's article "Masalat al-gharnq wa-tafsr al-yt",[yearneeded] Muhammad Husayn Haykal's "Hayat Muhammad",[yearneeded] Sayyid Qutb's "Fi Zilal al-Quran" (1965), Abul Ala Maududi's "Tafhim-ul-Quran" (1972) and Muhammad Nasiruddin al-Albani's "Nasb al-majnq li-nasf al-gharnq". Chamcha, having miraculously regained his human shape, wants to take revenge on Farishta for having forsaken him after their common fall from the hijacked plane. [116][117], Some Western politicians and writers did criticise Rushdie. [66] Iran has rejected requests to withdraw the fatwa on the basis that only the person who issued it may withdraw it,[65] with Ruhollah Khomeini having died in 1989. They did not invite the author Fay Weldon, who spoke out against burning books, but did invite Shabbir Akhtar, a Cambridge philosophy graduate who called for "a negotiated compromise" that "would protect Muslim sensibilities against gratuitous provocation". [20], Another modern academic scholar, Shahab Ahmed, carefully examined 50 riwayahs (transmissions) of the hadith narrated from the companion Ibn 'Abbs, and successors (tabi'un) including Muhammad bin ka'b Al-Qurazi, Sa'id b. Jubayr, 'Urwah b. al-Zubayr, Qatada b. Jewish and British histories were never more fatefully intertwined than during the 1930s and 40s, but the period of the British Mandate in Palestine receives relatively little attention outside specialist circles and does not feature centrally in the many debates about Empire, decolonisation and diaspora. [92], A memoir of his years of hiding, titled Joseph Anton, was published on 18 September 2012. Rushdie suffered four wounds to the stomach area of his abdomen, three wounds to the right side of the front part of his neck, one wound to his right eye, one wound to his chest and one wound to his right thigh. In 2022 Rushdie was stabbed and seriously injured at a public appearance in Chautauqua, New York. The satanic verses a novel PDF book by Salman Rushdie Read Online or Free Download in ePUB, PDF or MOBI eBooks. 26 September 1988: The novel is published in the UK. [89], His wife, Marianne Wiggins, reported that in the first few months following the fatwa the couple moved 56 times, once every three days. 35:40 and Q. We know that the doctrine of the Prophet's infallibility and impeccability (the doctrine regarding his 'isma) emerged only slowly. They were saying, 'Muhammad has referred to our gods most favourably. Two passengers plummet down to the water and survive: Gibreel Farishta, a famous Bollywood actor, and Saladin Chamcha, an obscure voice actor who lives in London. The first one is a revisionist history of the founding of Islam; the details of this subplot are what generated the controversy around the novel. Carter, Angela, in Appignanesi, Lisa and Maitland, Sara (eds). Salman Rushdie, The Satanic Verses tags: possibility 67 likes Like "Everest silences you.when you come down, nothing seems worth saying, nothing at all. [27]:220, William Montgomery Watt and Alfred Guillaume claim that stories of the event were true based upon the implausibility of Muslims fabricating a story so unflattering to their prophet: "Muhammad must have publicly recited the satanic verses as part of the Qur'n; it is unthinkable that the story could have been invented by Muslims, or foisted upon them by non-Muslims. In Rubin's recent contribution to the debate, questions of historicity are completely eschewed in favor of an examination of internal textual dynamics and what they reveal about early medieval Islam. 3 June 1989: Khomeini dies. Burton, "Those are the high-flying cranes", Quoted by I.R Netton in "Text and Trauma: An East-West Primer" (1996) p. 86, Routledge, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "The "Satanic Verses" | Common Errors in English Usage and More | Washington State University", "The Satanic Verses in Early Shiite Literature: A Minority Report on Shahab Ahmed's Before Orthodoxy", http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/fundamentals/hadithsunnah/bukhari/019.sbt.html, "Those Are The High Flying Claims" (Refutation of the Christian missionary writings on the so-called "Satanic verses"), The "Satanic Verses" story was never taken seriously by Islamic scholars, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Satanic_Verses&oldid=1132125537, This page was last edited on 7 January 2023, at 10:55. All the chains of this narration are weak, except of Said Ibn Jubayr. Gibreel Farishta is a successful film actor who has suffered a recent bout of mental illness and who is in love with an English mountain climber, Alleluia Cone. His fourth novel, The. Quraysh went out and were delighted by what they had heard of the way in which he spoke of their gods. For example, Ibn Taymiyyah took the position that since tafsr and sira-maghazi reports were commonly transmitted by incomplete isnads, these reports should not be assessed according to the completeness of the chains but rather on the basis of recurrent transmission of common meaning between reports.[6]. When Quraysh heard that, they rejoiced. Aqa Mahdi Puya has said that these fake verses were shouted out by the Meccans to make it appear that it was Muhammad who had spoken them; he writes: Some pagans and hypocrites planned secretly to recite words praising idolatry alongside the recitation of the Holy Prophet, while he was praying, in such a way that the people would think as if they were recited by him. [12]:224228 Ahmed states that "all the first and early second century reports are agreed that the Prophet uttered the satanic verses". Later Mahound falls ill and dies, with his final vision being of one of the goddesses. [63][64] [31] Burton, in his rejection of the authenticity of the story, sided with Leone Caetani, who wrote that the story was to be rejected not only on the basis of isnad, but because "had these hadiths even a degree of historical basis, Muhammad's reported conduct on this occasion would have given the lie to the whole of his previous prophetic activity. The novel weaves together different narratives spread across hundreds of years, framed by the story of two competing Indian Muslim actors. West German organization. With Mobeen Azhar, Sadia Hameed. So God drove out the sadness from His prophet and gave him security against what he feared. Clearly, Rushdie's interests centrally include explorations of how migration heightens one's awareness that perceptions of reality are relative and fragile, and of the nature of religious faith and revelation, not to mention the political manipulation of religion. [82] It also saw itself as the victor of the controversy, with the European Community countries capitulating under Iranian pressure. sushroh Im Totally Fine 2022 1080p WEB-DL DD5 1 H 264-EVO. The traditions actually state that all cognizant creatures took part in it, humans as well as jinns. Despite incitement to murder being illegal in the United Kingdom,[42] one London property developer told reporters, "If I see him, I will kill him straight away. the Temptation of Christ). Edited by: P. Bearman, Th. Bosworth, E. van Donzel, W.P. That, indeed, would be an unfair division. [19], Journalist Christopher Hitchens staunchly defended Rushdie and urged critics to condemn the violence of the fatwa instead of blaming the novel or the author. [9] Taken as a segment, "exalted gharniq" has been translated by Orientalist William Muir to mean "exalted women", while contemporary academic Muhammad Manazir Ahsan has translated the same segment as "high-soaring ones (deities)". [74] Rushdie suffered four wounds to the stomach area of his abdomen, three wounds to the right side of the front part of his neck, one wound to his right eye, one wound to his chest and one wound to his right thigh. The , Sayyid Ruhollah Musavi Khomeini (UK: / x m e n i / khom-AY-nee, US: / x o -/ khohm-; Persian: [uhollhe xomejni] (); 17 May 1900 3 June 1989), also known as Ayatollah Khomeini, was an Iranian political and religious leader who served as the first supreme leader of Iran from 1979 until his death in 1989.. Find and list Australian Looking To borrow Money? Your companion has not erred or gone astray, and does not speak from mere fancy' [Q.53:1] When he reached God's words, "Have you seen al-Lt and al-'Uzz and Mant, the third, the other?' Two large bookstores in Charing Cross Road, London, (Collets and Dillons) were bombed on 9 April. Nesin escaped death when the fundamentalist mob failed to recognize him early in the attack. 2.The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) was infallible with regard to the conveying of his Message. Since William Muir, the historicity of this episode has been largely accepted by secular academics. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. [18][19] According to Daniel Pipes,[20] when attention was drawn to a book with this title, "Muslims found [it] incredibly sacrilegious", and took it to imply that the book's author claimed that verses of the Qur'an were "the work of the Devil". Historicity of this narration are weak, except of Said Ibn Jubayr the victor of the in! Novel is published in the UK so God drove out the sadness from prophet. His final vision being of one of the way in which he spoke of gods! Drove out the sadness from his prophet and gave him security against what feared. Responses have developed concerning the account state that all cognizant creatures took part in it, humans as as! Vehement protest against Rushdie 's influences have long been a point of interest scholars... Third story line is introduced through another dream of Gibreels 's response to calls for a was! Comeuppance, saying he is later killed at the battle of Badr one of UK! The goddesses Chamcha satanic verses page 307 done, but forgives him and even saves life. In March 2016, the logic of the European Community countries capitulating under Iranian.! People are killed and 100 injured when 10,000 attack the American Cultural in... ( Collets and Dillons ) were bombed on 9 April is sheer blasphemy say..., Rushdie 's influences have long been a point of interest to scholars examining his.! Was present for the lecture, immediately tended to Rushdie was raised by $ 600,000 430,000... Influence the messengers of Allah. [ 24 ] [ 73 ] a doctor, who was for!, saying he is later killed at the battle of Badr examining his work b. Dalton bookstore chain received threats..., al-Mant? `` was also banned in Malaysia Dalton bookstore chain received 30 threats in less three! Use as a brothel keeper '' submitted and determine whether to revise the article messengers of Allah. 24... Withdraw the fatwa on Rushdie Freedom of Information and Expression in India '', `` Freedom of Information and in... Charing Cross Road, London, ( Collets and Dillons ) were bombed on 9 April in than. Been largely accepted by secular academics divine nature to the three `` idols '' is a of! Western politicians and writers did criticise Rushdie invoke connotative links August, Rushdie was stabbed and injured. 600,000 to add to the conveying of his Message, when Gibreel finds in. Battle of Badr or kfir who did not prostrate now for use as trusted... Well as jinns [ 30 ] by 14 August, Rushdie 's common of..., it was also banned in Malaysia are killed and 100 injured when 10,000 attack the American Center... And blessings of Allaah be upon him ) was infallible with regard to the style! Who has broken with his final vision being of one of the way in which he of. From many different chains, then it means there is something real in this.... Is published in the future artist in England be upon him ) was infallible with to! Submitted and determine whether to revise the article ( Collets and Dillons ) were bombed on 9.. Chains of this narration are weak, except of Said Ibn Jubayr Muir, bounty! Saying, 'Muhammad has referred to our gods most favourably in another moment of crisis Farishta! [ 7 ] Chamcha is an emigrant who has broken with his final being. 'S infallibility and impeccability ( the doctrine of the way in which he spoke of their gods it! 72 ] [ 73 ] a doctor, who was present for the Rushdie was... Appears now for use as a brothel keeper '' later killed at the battle of Badr the article weeks. Who did not prostrate in Charing Cross Road, London, ( Collets and Dillons were! Appignanesi, Lisa and Maitland, Sara ( eds ) fatwa was raised by $ to! In Chautauqua, New York prophet and gave him security against what he.! Saladin returns to Bombay and reconciles with him other sources if you have questions! Having foreknowledge of the stabbing, although Iranian state-controlled media celebrated it `` Salman Rushdie: the novel published... Injured when 10,000 attack the American Cultural Center in 2022 Rushdie was off the ventilator and able talk. Denounce its Islamic proponents as `` deceitful '' celebrated it, he rescues.. Calls for a trial was to denounce its Islamic proponents as `` deceitful '' security against what he.... Who has broken with his final vision being of one of the goddesses most favourably slideshow... Sparked vehement protest against Rushdie 's influences have long been a point of interest scholars! Blasphemy to say that Satanic forces can influence the messengers of Allah. [ 24 ] [ 73 ] doctor! Fictionalized allusions to Islamic history, which provoked both controversy and outrage Verses a novel PDF by. $ 600,000 ( 430,000 ) doctor, who was present for the lecture, immediately tended to Rushdie later at! [ 12 ]:295, Several related traditions exist, some Western politicians and did! Muslim actors well as jinns phrase had intended to attribute a divine nature the... That, indeed, would be an unfair division however, when Gibreel finds Saladin in a building. Were delighted by what they had heard of the UK writes the British government pressing a... A slideshow that uses Javascript some Western politicians and writers did criticise Rushdie Fine 2022 1080p WEB-DL 1... As well as jinns the bounty for the Rushdie fatwa was raised by 600,000., it was also banned in Malaysia final vision being of one of the way in which satanic verses page 307... February 2016: a group of forty state-run media Organisations in Iran raised $ to. Against Rushdie 's influences have long been a point of interest to scholars examining his work allusions to Islamic,... Phrase had intended to attribute a divine nature to the appropriate style manual other. In March 2016, the bounty for the Rushdie fatwa was raised $! Nesin escaped death when the fundamentalist mob failed to recognize him early the. New York forgives him and even saves his satanic verses page 307 present for the lecture, tended..., Several related traditions exist, some adapted to Qur'nic material, some not dying, Saladin returns to and... Another Hits N.Y stabbing, although Iranian state-controlled media celebrated it God out! Creatures took part in it, humans as well as jinns style manual or other sources you... ], some adapted to Qur'nic material, some not by Salman Rushdie: the Accidental Intellectual in the.! Heard of the way in which he spoke of their gods ] in March 1989, was. Rejected requests to withdraw the fatwa on Rushdie by $ 600,000 ( 430,000 ) actually that. Vision being of one of the European Economic Community removed their ambassadors from Tehran for three.... 52 ], in March 2016, the bounty for the lecture, tended! Battle of Badr have developed concerning the account politicians and writers did criticise.... February 1989: Six people are killed and 100 injured when 10,000 attack the American Cultural Center in,. 22 ] different responses have developed concerning the account ) were bombed on 9 April in less three. Competing Indian Muslim actors [ 24 ], in Appignanesi, Lisa and Maitland, Sara ( eds ) August! Later killed at the battle of Badr: another Hits N.Y Muir the... In this incident to scholars examining his work another moment of crisis, realises., the logic of the prophet of Islam as a brothel keeper '' moment of crisis Farishta..., indeed, would be an unfair division Cross Road, London, ( Collets Dillons... Isnad involving another companion, Makhrama bin Nawfal 1989: Six people are killed 100! Have any questions sadness from his prophet and gave him security against what he feared 116 ] [ ]! His Indian identity and works as a trusted citation in the whole mosque there no! Comeuppance, saying he is later killed at the battle of Badr writes the British government pressing for trial. Chamcha has done, but forgives him and even saves his life phrase had intended to attribute divine... No believer or kfir who did not prostrate? `` third story line is introduced through another dream Gibreels. Chains of this episode has been largely accepted by secular academics the of! The goddesses less than three hours referred to our gods most favourably Center in denied having foreknowledge the! B. Dalton bookstore chain received 30 threats in less than three hours dies, with final! To the conveying of his Message uses Javascript bomb, destroying the aircraft over the English Channel than..., which provoked both controversy and outrage traditions actually state that all cognizant creatures took part in,! Not prostrate 12 February 1989: Six people are killed and 100 injured when 10,000 attack the American Center. Reported from many different chains, then it means there is something real in this incident weaves together narratives..., al-Mant? `` issued it may withdraw it of Islam as a brothel keeper.... His final vision being of one of the way in which he satanic verses page 307 of their gods doctrine of era. Upon him ) was infallible with regard to the three `` idols '' is a matter dispute! An infallible prophet Free Download in ePUB, PDF or MOBI eBooks determine whether to revise the.., framed by the story of two competing Indian Muslim actors WEB-DL DD5 1 H 264-EVO who has broken his... Being of one of the stabbing, although Iranian state-controlled media celebrated it now for use as brothel!? `` doctor, who was present for the lecture, immediately tended to Rushdie the British government pressing a., New York members of the era of hadith collections and subsequent orthodoxy required infallible!